Penman warns “self-styled disruptor” Cummings of “the realities of running government”

Graham Martin
FDA General Secretary Dave Penman has responded to Dominic Cummings’ recent appointment as a chief advisor to Boris Johnson with a cautionary message: there is a difference between “theoretical radicalism” and the reality of government.
Speaking on this appointment, Penman said: “Dominic Cummings, like self-styled disruptors before him such as Steve Hilton, quickly find their theoretical radicalism clashes with the realities of running government and the complexities of delivering vital public services. There’s a huge difference between bringing in new ideas or radical agendas and implementing untested ideologies which, if they go wrong, will impact upon the delivery of public services to millions of citizens.”
Cummings, the former head of the Vote Leave campaign, has a history of criticising civil servants. He has described a permanent civil service as “an idea for the history books”, and stated that he would “get rid of permanent secretaries”.
Penman also noted the reason behind Johnson’s decision, explaining that “every new Prime Minister, impatient to see their bold agenda delivered, comes into office with a thirst to shake things up and think the unthinkable. The appointment of Dominic Cummings is clearly this Prime Minister’s signal of intent.”
The General Secretary’s warning extended to Johnson, as he noted that “ultimately, it will be for the Prime Minister and ministers to decide on the government’s agenda – with advice from the civil service and special advisers – as they will ultimately be accountable for any success or failure of any policy, including untested theoretical ones.”
His comments were covered by i newspaper and The Guardian.
Related News
-
“FDA is not afraid of civil service reform, but it has to have substance”
FDA General Secretary Dave Penman responds to the government’s latest announcement on the reshaping and renewal of the state.
-
Government’s plans for civil service reform “lack substance”, says FDA
The FDA has criticised the government’s rhetoric surrounding the announcement of a series of civil service reforms – on performance-based pay, fast track exits for underperformers, and performance management – by Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster Pat McFadden.
-
FDA attends TUC Women’s Conference 2025
A delegation of FDA members attended TUC Women’s Conference 2025, held in Congress House, London, from 5-7 March.